- 1984 – 87: Tim Giago
- 1987 – 88: Mike Burgess
- 1988 – 92: Mark Trahant
- 1992 – 94: Paul DeMain
- 1994 – 96: Karen Lincoln Michel
- 1996: Keith Skenandore
- 1996 – 98: Paul DeMain
- 1998 – 99: Kara Briggs
- 1999 – 2000: Lori Edmo-Suppah
- 2000 – 02: Mary Annette Pember
- 2002 – 04: Patty Talahongva
- 2004 – 05: Dan Lewerenz
- 2005 – 07: Mike Kellogg
- 2007 – 08: Cristina Azocar
- 2008 – 10: Ronnie Washines
- 2010 – 11: Rhonda LeValdo
- 2011: Darla Leslie
- 2011 – 13: Rhonda LeValdo
- 2013 – 15: Mary Hudetz
- 2015 – 16: Jason Begay
- 2016 – 18: Bryan Pollard
- 2018 – 20: Tristan Ahtone
- 2021: Graham Lee Brewer
